Honors College
Student Outcomes
Assessment of Student Outcomes
Outcome A Interdisciplinarity
Demonstrate appropriate interdisciplinary perspectives, research
approaches, and theories across the liberal arts and sciences.
Objective 6
Honors students will demonstrate broad knowledge across the disciplines.
Measure 1
2016 Status
Achieved
74.3% of our juniors and seniors scored "proficient" or
"distinguished" in content knowledge across the disciplines in
the 2013-16 GE assessment.
Measure 2
2017 Status
Not Yet Achieved
We assessed 47 students in Honors physical sciences classes in Fall 2017
in three knowledge areas.
Measure 3
2017 Status
Not Yet Achieved
We're close here, just a few percentage points below our target.
Measure 4
2017 Status
Achieved
In Fall 2017, we assessed students in HNR 231 (Holocaust) for their
content knowledge in the social and behavioral sciences.
Objective 7
Honors students will demonstrate the ability to integrate the content,
data, methods, tools, concepts, or theories from two or more disciplines
in order to advance ideas, address issues, or solve problems that are
too broad for a single approach.
Measure 1
2019 Status
Achieved
Professors Cataldo and McFarland 1) analyzed syllabi from all our
first-year sequences, reading them for certain keywords and questions
associated with our curriculum revision; 2) analyzed faculty comments on
student written work, for same; and surveyed second-year Honors students
about whether their first-year Honors sequences emphasized those
keywords and questions.
Outcome B Communication skills
Demonstrate communication skills in order to articulate complex ideas.
Objective 1
Honors students will demonstrate strong writing skills.
Measure 1
2016 Status
Achieved
Our 2015 round of assessment resulted in gradual increase in writing
skills. The senior projects were rated at 94.4%, well above our target.
Measure 2
2016 Status
Achieved
in our 2013-16 GE assessments, 76% of our juniors and seniors rated as
"proficient" or "distinguished" in written communication.
Measure 3
2019 Status
Achieved
This assessment was completed in Winter 2019, and the final report was
submitted May 1, 2019.
Measure 4
2021 Status
Achieved
We had four expert WRT 150 graders score 177 first-year Honors student
papers using standard WRT 150 grading criteria in five evaluation
categories: content/research, organization, style,
citation/documentation, and mechanics. The overall Honors
"GPA" suggested by the scoring is 3.12 (a B+) compared the the
actual Fall 2020 WRT 150 GPA of 2.78 (a B-). Thus, as expected, Honors
students generally outperform their non-Honors counterparts. More
specifically, Honors students performed best in the categories of
mechanics (3.52), content/research (3.10), and style (3.09). Their
lowest scores were in organization (2.99) and citation/documentation (2.93).
2020 Status
Not Yet Achieved
Our initial plan was to conduct this assessment in May 2020, but the
COVID closure prevented that--so we will have to set our sights on May
2021. We'll be using WRT faculty, and we want to do it when they are not teaching.
Objective 5
Honors students will demonstrate strong oral communication skills.
Measure 1
2016 Status
Not Yet Achieved
Our most recent GE assessment indicates that 62.5% of our juniors and
seniors scored "proficient" or "distinguished" in
oral communication.
Outcome C Intellectual independence
Demonstrate intellectual independence and the ability to articulate
arguments that critically analyze information from a variety of sources
and perspectives.
Objective 4
Honors students will demonstrate intellectual curiosity and habits of
mind that lead to a continual pursuit of knowledge and independent thought.
Measure 1
2016 Status
Achieved
The 2015 exist survey administered by the former director resulted in
95% of students reporting that Honors helped them develop intellectual
curiosity and good habits of learning.
Measure 2
2018 Status
Achieved
On the self-assessment questionnaire: We found that, ironically,
students generally lowered their self-ratings on most of the
"habits of mind" items from the time they applied to the
Honors College to the time they graduated. They did report higher
ratings in terms of setting high expectations for themselves, working
independently, scheduling their time, and their interest in meeting
interesting people--and we view these as very positive developments.
However, they self-rated themselves lower in terms of completing
assigned readings, paying attention to the news, being comfortable with
vague assignments, enjoying sharing new ideas with others, and enjoying
"big issue" classes. The first two of these seem to us an
unsurprising reflection of moving from high school to college, and they
don't concern us. The other three, however, seem important for us to
reflect on--and we are doing so. On the graduating senior reflections:
We're delighted by the depth and maturity of the senior reflections (see
the attached PDF), which we grouped into four areas: reflections on the
living/learning community, reflections on faculty, reflections on the
curriculum, and reflections on the skills they've learned. We see these
reflections as a strong affirmation of our program's contribution to the
growing intellectual independence of Honors students.
Measure 3
2019 Status
Achieved
Advisors Kelly McDonell and Meg Marshall surveyed 421 Honors students in
Winter 2019 and then conducted focus groups with a small number of
students afterward. The focus of the survey and focus groups was how
Honors students currently engaged the program and university--and how
they might increase that engagement in the future. We see such
engagement as a positive sign of growing intellectual independence.
Measure 4
2020 Status
Achieved
We had 17 productive and insightful conversations with about 350 of our
students, and we shared the students' insights and reflections with all
35 current sequence faculty as part of a continuing effort to make the
first-year experience as enriching as possible for Honors students.
Outcome D Advanced critical thinking
Demonstrate advanced critical thinking skills at levels required for
effective performance in professional and other social and cultural contexts.
Objective 2
Honors students will demonstrate exceptional growth towards
"self-authorship" (constructing knowledge using
information-gathering skills, keen analysis, sophisticated arguments,
and multiple perspectives/disciplinary methodologies).
Measure 1
2016 Status
Not Yet Achieved
In our 2013-16 GE assessments, 69% of our juniors and seniors rated at
"proficient" or "distinguished" in critical thinking.
Measure 2
2019 Status
Achieved
Professors Toot and Baum surveyed 7 Honors science faculty, examined
syllabi from 8 Honors science courses, and surveyed 47 Honors science students.
Outcome E Global citizenship
Demonstrate an understanding of the ethical and moral obligations of an
informed and engaged global citizen.
Objective 3
Honors students will demonstrate global citizenship--they will be able
to articulate key global issues and express concern about them and
willingness to address them.
Measure 1
2019 Status
Not Yet Achieved
Of Honors students graduating in December 2018 and April 2019, 37.4%
reported having studied abroad during their time at GVSU.
2017 Status
Not Yet Achieved
Our percentage of seniors who report studying abroad dropped between
2015 and 2017, from about 40% to about 25%. It's still a high number,
and part of the drop can be attributed to some external factors, but we
are committed to improving.
Measure 2
2016 Status
Achieved
In our 2015 exit survey, 97% of students reported gaining a deeper
understanding of global issues through Honors.